Thursday, January 28, 2021

Six reasons why high school students should never return to school full-time

Applying the insights gained from the COVID-19 experience

Reading Time: 4 minutes
high school students

High school students should only go to school for four days per week. They should spend one day a week using well-crafted blended learning. For what have we learned if after COVID we go back to where we were prior? There are numerous good reasons as to why this should be the model of education that we pursue in a post-pandemic world.

Reason 1: Improved learning

- Advertisement -

Teachers who have successfully adapted online learning have understood that shortcomings in everyday classrooms are highlighted if blended online learning is not well designed. This is an important insight that the recent experience has revealed. Poor classroom practice is amplified in an online learning space.

The great benefit of the well designed and considered online learning is that students can learn at their own pace, in a structured environment, with their peers or individually. It is ideal for students who are shy, those who are distractible, those who are gifted and those who like structured, self-paced modules.  Online learning teaches the value of being organised.

The learning can be complemented by face-to-face conferencing as required. Indeed little-used forms of teaching – such as co-teaching – can be applied to maximise the benefit to students working online.

In terms of attendance, of course, rolls would still be marked and mandatory course hours still completed.

Reason 2: Greater equity for children with particular needs

On the day that students would spend at home (as timetabled by their school), those students who have access to fewer resources can come on campus and use the library to do their classes. Additionally, those students who by necessity must be at school would also do so.

The greatest benefit is for those students who have a need for additional face-to-face time due to their particular learning needs. The best place where this is done is at school.

This means that using well-designed online resources actually frees up additional resources to support those most in need – a real equity and access gain for those left behind during the pandemic, and those more generally always left behind due to competition for limited resources.

Reason 3: Visible learning

During this period of home-based schooling and home-based work, parents have been, for the first time, able to see behind the veneer of school gates and classroom walls. This means that they have heard and seen what happens in a classroom. This exposure is important for parents to understand how education works. It has created a new respect for teachers. This is important, as is the capacity for this to bring new levels of accountability of the education sector to parents. I call this ‘visible learning’ and see it as an essential component of future classrooms.

Reason 4: Improved environmental outcomes

Online learning has meant less printing, less commuting and less wasted time. Evidently, the environment has improved during the lockdown period. To go back to the hurry of the world prior to the period of forced slowdown and reflection would be madness. That was for then – but with the benefit of time we can plan a world we want.

Schooling from home one day per week has an additional benefit in that students – most likely to suffer most from environmental inaction – will recognise that the new structures respect their fears and are doing something to ameliorate them. Moreover, it will role model to students that intelligent design and creative problem solving can be applied to real world present problems. Systems can bend to good ideas rather than being inflexible in the light of evidence suggesting alternatives might be better.

Reason 5: Lower costs

The delivery of online learning means that the actual cost of education can be reduced making it more affordable, more accessible and more available. Less travel means less spending and less time in unproductive commuting. Whilst there would need to be some cost incurred in the initial investment in staff time to create well-considered models of what will work best and how, once this investment has been made, the model is extremely low cost to iterate and improve.

Reason 6: Improved use and longevity of infrastructure

There are rational economic reasons as to why high schoolers should attend school four days per week and do the fifth day at home. Fewer people moving means that the roads will be less congested meaning economic productivity will rise. Families will have more time. Moreover, the actual roads and transportation infrastructure will be less utilised thus increasing their longevity.

Other considerations

Whilst there may be an impact on families, evidence has shown that modern, efficient workplaces can be structured around either a four-day week or be just as productive if parents work from home a day a week. This needs to be considered urgently – post-COVID, people will not accept the arbitrary nature of long ‘at work’ hours if productive work can be done at home.

In summary

With the rush to re-open high schools, it seems to me wasteful if a huge opportunity to restructure how schooling is done is not taken seriously. Policy-makers need to urgently consider what schools do and how, and then make changes that are consistent with the insight gained from the pandemic experience. Four-days at school for high schoolers seems an easy starting point.

READ ALSO:A new start at school

- Advertisement -
Mohan Dhall
Academic leader, M2K Education and Advisory and CEO of Australian Tutoring Association and Global Tutoring Association.

Related Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Ep8: Indian links in Indigenous Australian poet Ali Cobby Eckermann’s life

To celebrate NAIDOC week 2020 (between 8-15 November) I spoke to Yakunytjatjara poet Ali Cobby Eckermann about her time in India where she taught...

Ep 7: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

  The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Ep 6: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

  It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Latest News

WATCH: When Shehnai asks Violin to go to Khandala

  See what happens when India's shehnai and Italy's violin collaborate to produce a cover of Ae Kya Bolti tu, a song originally sung by...
Sheikh Hasina thanks India for 2 million vaccine doses

Vaccine diplomacy: India helps its neighbours in ‘Vaccine Maitri’ initiative

  In what is being called 'vaccine diplomacy' India has pledged to help seven of its neighbours in the fight against COVID-19. The gift, a...
pregnant woman vaccine

Pregnant? What are your thoughts on the COVID vaccine?

  As if expecting a baby during a global pandemic wasn’t stressful enough, many expectant mothers are now faced with a dilemma ahead of the...
wagah border ceremony

WATCH: Attari-Wagah Border Ceremony on India’s 72nd Republic Day

  It's always a sight to behold - watching the daily military practice between Indian and Pakistani forces at the Attari-Wagah border, made special on...
President Joe Biden

Huge relief for spouses of H1B workers in the US

  "Withdrawn". A single word on a thick bureaucratic file on the seventh day of the Biden administration delivered a huge win for spouses of...