Wednesday, January 20, 2021

You have stolen my Shiva

Reading Time: 3 minutesArt dealer Subhash Kapoor is taken to court for illegally selling the NGA a 900-year-old bronze Indian statue, reports LENA PEACOCK


- Advertisement -

 The National Gallery of Australia (NGA) in Canberra has taken New York art dealer Subhash Kapoor to court over the purchase of an 11th century bronze statue of Shiva as Lord of the Dance (Nataraja). The NGA is seeking the return of the $5 million it paid for the statue, plus legal fees and other costs. This artwork was purchased from Kapoor in 2008 for $5 million by the NGA, but in 2006 it was stolen from a Sivan Temple in the Ariyalur District of Tamil Nadu in southern India. False provenance papers were created by dealership Art of the Past, prior to selling it to the NGA. The false supporting documents included a letter of provenance stating that the statue had been purchased by a diplomat in India prior to 1971.

Kapoor is also facing charges in India over art smuggling allegations.

The NGA had previously bought 21 items through Kapoor’s art dealership, which the Australian government has now asked the gallery to investigate. These works were bought from Kapoor for A$11 million, and the deals were finalised between 2002 and 2011.

“We are going to deal with the Indian high commission with a view to pursuing the matter to a satisfactory outcome”, said Australian Arts Minister and Attorney-General George Brandis.

Repatriation is an issue that affects many artworks exported from India and it is hoped that this case draws further attention to stolen works. “The trade in artefacts and antiquities is a minefield for public galleries, being littered with fakes and phoney provenances such as the one supplied with the Shiva Nataraj”, writes Australian art historian John McDonald on his website. “The NGA’s rapid acquisition of so many Indian pieces was a strange fad pursued with reckless abandon”. McDonald questions whether this statue will “be the catalyst that destroys the NGA’s insularity and creates a new relationship with the public”. After all, the metre-high figure of Shiva surrounded by a ring of fire does represent both the creation and destruction of the world.

Jason Felch, a reporter and the author of Chasing Aphrodite: the Hunt for Looted Antiquities in the World’s Museum, says the gallery should have known better and did not do enough to find out if the statue’s provenance records were genuine. “There was a credible amount of evidence that a lot of the ancient art available for sale was coming with forged documents and bogus ownership histories to cover up the fact that they’d been recently stolen”, he says. “In 2006-2007, when this object was being considered by the National Gallery, there was an international controversy going on about museums acquiring ancient art”. Felch also questions whether, after the US authorities have seized $100 million of Kapoor’s art collection, there will “be money left over for the National Gallery to recoup?”

“Based on information obtained… the Shiva has lost its financial value, and its clouded title and notoriety means that the work cannot be promoted as a key work of art in the gallery’s Indian collection”, court documents read. And any attempts to sell the work are unlikely to occur because of the uncertainty surrounding its past, the document also states.

NGA have confirmed that they have contacted the Indian government to “discuss avenues for restitution” for the statue; however, a spokesperson for the gallery said they were unable to comment on the court case, as it is before the court. The spokesperson also declined to comment on how the federally funded gallery is paying for the court action.

- Advertisement -

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Ep8: Indian links in Indigenous Australian poet Ali Cobby Eckermann’s life

To celebrate NAIDOC week 2020 (between 8-15 November) I spoke to Yakunytjatjara poet Ali Cobby Eckermann about her time in India where she taught...

Ep 7: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

  The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Ep 6: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

  It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Latest News

washington sundar

After dramatic entry into Test cricket, Sundar steals the show

  How quickly fortune changes is evident in the dramatic manner in which Washington Sundar, originally selected only for the T20 series in Australia, was...

WATCH: Day 5 of the Gabba Test in 8 minutes

  Even those only remotely interested in cricket tuned in, and stayed glued to their screens yesterday. Has Test cricket ever been this interesting? From wickets...

Reliving the Gabba Test

  Chasing down a total of 328 at The Gabba, Australia's fortress for the last 33 years, the Indian team defied all odds to win...

A poetic tribute to Team India

  Since invincible Team India played an utterly exhausting four-Test series with the deciding Test at a venue at which Australia had not lost in...

Our favourite fan posters from AusVInd matches 2020-21

  We are so grateful that COVID didn't manage to completely remove fan presence from stadium grounds during this epic Indian tour of Australia. As...