Tuesday, January 26, 2021

Rethinking the feminist identity

Reading Time: 4 minutes

It’s important we respect different approaches to feminism

Feminism is a word that comes with decades of baggage and has numerous definitions. For some it is about advocating for women’s rights and equality of the sexes, while for others it is more of a political and social movement, an ideological agenda. The concept of feminism is fluid, subjective and open to adaptation by women (and men) in their respective and varying social, political and economic climates.
Identifying as feminist has not always been easy for people to accept. Indeed, some women dislike identifying as a feminist and the term has been utilised in political and consumerist manoeuvres which have tarnished its essence.
feminism.Indian Link
Born out the desire of white women in the western world to be recognised as an equal and valuable members of society, feminism has become synonymous with a myriad of statements and causes that have expanded to include racial, political and economic struggles.
Feminists have been traditionally thought of as bra burning, man hating, equality hungry, respect seeking, power hunting, hairy women. Disappointingly, these qualities are not seen as positive by society at large and the idea of being a feminist was (and still is) frowned upon in many circles. Especially in South Asian women, the double standards of wanting equality and respect, but deferring to a knight in shining armour to provide and love them is a worrying trend.
feminism.Indian Link
What does this mean? Does a feminist South Asian woman exist at all? Does she have to be short haired, butch and single? Or is she merely a figment of our imagination? It is imperative we question the status of feminism in Australia and South Asia respectively to understand who the Australian South Asian woman is and what her feminist reality looks like.
Feminism in Australian society has been largely defined by the developments taking place in America and Europe. Younger generations of Australian men and women are not familiar with the Germaine Greers of Australian feminism and, even if they are, find this stance to be divisive rather than helpful to the integration of feminism into mainstream discourse. The famous Julia Gillard Misogyny Speech was received well in Australia largely due to its global recognition.
feminism.Indian Link
Feminism in South Asia has been largely frowned upon, and whenever it came to the fore of social discourse, it was tinged with an ulterior motive. The English and Dutch colonisers used it to point out the tradition of structured subjugation of women as lower class citizens, then the political elite used it to ‘emancipate’ that same class of women into a new era of post-colonial ‘freedom’ where oppression was merely hidden under a different veil – sometimes literally. Hindu and Muslim women who covered themselves out of deference to their faith were mocked as the trends and fashions of post-colonial life pressured women into ‘freeing’ their minds and bodies both figuratively and literally.
Fast forward another 50 years and the rampant abuse of women both within and outside the home, the escalation in reported rapes and domestic violence, prove that women can wear what they want and say what they want but, until men are taught to respect a woman’s right to do as she pleases, feminism is and will remain a mythical ideal to which South Asian culture aspires (or not)?

What does this mean for the South Asian woman living in an Australian society? How can she grow out of the murky entrenched ‘values’ of shy deference and obedience that have been imbued gradually over centuries of instruction, to accept that seeking respect for her right to think and do as she pleases is as inherent in her psyche as it is to breathe.

- Advertisement -

That right can be called whatever you like, but it signifies a woman’s right to choose for herself. A woman who chooses to give up her career for a role as homemaker can be every bit a feminist as a woman who shuns the ‘traditional’ role for a more ‘masculine’ one. But women cannot do this alone. We co-exist with a male population that is just as crucial to the embedding of feminism in our social fabric as women themselves. Men have to accept, respect and encourage feminism with the same ardour as women for the concept to have any meaningful impact on our lives.
feminism.Indian Link
Feminism is genuinely showing respect for another individual.
Feminism is rejecting stereotypes of what a woman ‘should’ be doing with her life by a certain age and embracing that every life, every situation is different and equally worthy.
Feminism is the way we frame our discourse to abandon the classification of jobs as masculine or feminine, as traditional or untraditional.
Feminism is accepting that men and women are created differently physically and psychologically to serve differing purposes in life – each no more significant than the other.
Feminism is understanding how to engage in honest but polite discourse with another person, be it a man or a woman and respecting their personal space, wants and needs.
Feminism is – whatever you want it to be. It is an identity that you own and shape by upholding the values of love, respect and honesty. Whether you are a man or a woman, you can embrace your history, your religion, your culture and your values to form your own distinctly creative feminist identity.

- Advertisement -
Shafeen Mustaq
Shafeen is a Sydney based writer

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Ep8: Indian links in Indigenous Australian poet Ali Cobby Eckermann’s life

To celebrate NAIDOC week 2020 (between 8-15 November) I spoke to Yakunytjatjara poet Ali Cobby Eckermann about her time in India where she taught...

Ep 7: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

  The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Ep 6: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

  It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Latest News

aboriginal flag

Indigenous Australians, living without conciliation

  I am a citizen of Australia and yet I am not a citizen of the nation I reside in within Australia. This anomaly affects...

The night we fled our home in Kashmir

  “26 January is coming up, memsaab,” the milkman I had known for years said to me. “Maybe you should put up a black flag...
the white tiger netflix

Review: The White Tiger (Netflix)

  "Don't believe for a second there's a million-rupee game show you can win to get out of it". That's Balram Halwai in The White...
lilly singh

WATCH: Lilly Singh as Sima Taparia in “Indian Matchbreaking”

  Whether we liked it or not, most of us gave into the Sima Taparia craze during lockdown. Within days, we'd all binged on Netflix's...
karl rock

From New Zealand to New Delhi: Meet YouTube’s Karl Rock

  When Karl Rock picks up the phone (with a cheerful ‘Namaste!’ no less), his New Zealand accent is apparent. That is, until he bursts...