Wednesday, October 28, 2020

Islam through a different lens

< 1 minute read

Ed Husain talks about the mainstream and pluralist form of Islam with Tasneem Chopra at the Melbourne Writers Festival

“The House is a faith and a civilisation, the House is an identity…the House is emotion, the House is meaning, the House is belonging.”
This is how Ed Husain, author of The House of Islam: A Global History described ‘The House of Islam’, in discussion with Tasneem Chopra at the Melbourne Writers Festival.
Husain, who has also authored The Islamist, spoke to us about the impetus for this ambitious new book on Islam, and the state of his faith – shared by 1.6 billion people around the world – today.

Ed Husain The House Of Islam.Indian Link
Tasneem Chopra and Ed Husain

“That’s one in five humans around the world in the news on daily basis, rightly or wrongly. But we know very little about them.” Through The House of Islam, he hoped to “better explain the lived reality and collective memory of ordinary Muslims”.
He had another audience as well: his fellow Muslims, especially those born and raised in the West as he was. “I wanted to explain a mainstream, normal, compassionate, kind, pluralist form of Islam to a new generation of Muslims.”
Husain detailed his theory of why Islam, a political and cultural superpower, the faith of “the ruling class, the elite”, for nearly 1,200 years, lost its glory and influence. From 1500 onwards, the West, previously far behind the civilisations of Islam in sophistication, knowledge and culture, suddenly emerged as a rival. “It was a big shock. The Muslims have spent the last hundred years trying to catch up, to compete with the West.”
One happy and ahead-of-its-time consequence of this, by the way, was the decriminalisation of homosexuality in the Ottoman Empire in 1857. However, Husain said the humiliation of being bested by the West has left deep “pyschological trauma.”
He cited the Pakistan/India division as a key example of that trauma – Muslims unable to come to terms with not having hegemonic power.
Husain also spoke about the importance of Sufism to mainstream Islam, something he said had been misunderstood by the West. “There’s a spectrum of Sufism…most Muslims are somewhere in between. Almost all Muslims have a connection to Sufism [although] they may not know it.” This lack of knowledge and connection to Sufism, he said, was what had led to the problems within the faith today.
This is something he spoke frankly about: the distancing of that “compassionate, kind, contemplative, mystical form [of Islam]”. Without it, he said, he “feared for the future of the Muslim world”.
Ed Husain The House Of Islam.Indian Link
Islam, he said, could live comfortably within “a pluralist, secular West” – the dangers had come with the rise of ‘Islamism’, which seeks “to make law” what is private and personal: “between me and God.”
The diminishing of Islam’s intellectual culture, through political and religious repression, concerned him deeply. “We haven’t produced a serious Muslim thinker since the 18th century…in the Arab world there’s a serious lack of thought and freedom.”  As he pointed out, the situation was once the complete reverse. After all, “the greatest defender of Aristotle in the 13th century” was the philosopher Averroes, i.e. the Muslim scholar Ibn Rushd.
He worried for the future of the Muslim diaspora in the West – people turning away from the faith and then “turning on it”,  which he sees as a real possibility. “I worry where that leads to…Muslims seen as backward, with no space in the modern world…there needs to be a recognition that Muslims (in the West) are children of the soil. They’re not going anywhere.”

However, he was, perhaps controversially, firm about the Muslim world needing to take more responsibility for the negative perceptions of the faith. “As a Westerner and a Muslim, I think we need to own up to some of the difficulties that we Muslims don’t want to look in the mirror for.”

When it came to Islamaphobia, he said it was driven in part by extremists who have “antagonised the social contract we have with the West…the way we push back and reclaim sanity in the West is to hit back against the fascist far right that use Islamaphobia, but also hit back against the extremists in our midst.”
Finally, he positioned his book as “more centrist” than other recent books on Islam. “Many of those other Muslim writers in the past have called for some form of Sharia – for me, Sharia is already here [in the West]. If you didn’t know that, sorry, I’ve got news for you – Australia is already a compliant country.”
Sharia, he said, means the preservation of life, property, religion, family and intellect.
“Sorry Pauline Hanson,” he laughed.

- Advertisement -
Aparna Ananthuni
Aparna is an aspiring writer of historical fiction and fantasy for young adults and children. She also loves reading, drawing and Indian classical music, and often develops strange obsessions like typewriter-collecting.

Related Articles

*LAST DAY TODAY* Design our Diwali greeting card – Join the art competition!

It’s back again this year: Indian Link's annual Diwali arts competition for kids! Like every year, we are seeking...

Why pauses are important in migrant women’s lives

Migration brings a drastic change in the social lives of women, whether it is rural-urban migration within a country, or a move...

Designer Srishti Kaur creates beard-friendly COVID masks

If many of us find wearing ordinary masks uncomfortable - tugging at the ears, fogging up our glasses, and riding up the...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -


Episode Seven: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Episode Six: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Episode Five: Oz media fails diversity test again

As per a report that was published last week, Australian media seems to have again failed to represent the country’s diversity accurately onscreen. The...
- Advertisement -

Latest News

women of sister project in perth

Sister Project, empowering women of diverse backgrounds

Ellenbrook local Tracey Cave had always wanted to do something community-oriented. But it wasn’t until she saw a fellow Mum, who was a migrant...
melbourne city

Melbourne unlocked: What’s the post-restrictions plan?

Some excitement about "overpriced gourmet coffee" with some caution about socialising and hygiene - here's how Melbournians are accepting the easing of Melbourne's restrictions...

Steve Waugh’s India: where cricket gives hope and happiness

"I always wanted to get into the alleyways, the backstreets, in the mountains, in the desert, the beaches; just see people playing cricket and...
India Tour of Australia dates

Fixtures for India’s tour of Australia released

The upcoming months promise an exciting season for cricket with three series – the Vodafone Test series, Dettol ODI series, and Dettol Twenty20 International...
covid stats on phone

How do we know statistics can be trusted? We talked to...

  In April, as the coronavirus pandemic was gathering force around the world, reporters asked Brendan Murphy, then Australia’s...