Wednesday, January 20, 2021

Why cricket is more than just cricket

Reading Time: 3 minutes

The gentleman’s game, more than any other, has become a test of national loyalty, given the subcontinent’s troubled history

A few weeks before I permanently moved to Sydney, India played Australia in the Cricket World Cup 2015 Semi-Finals. That game presented to me an unenviable choice evoking Shakespearean emotions. I am sure a lot of immigrants empathise with this dilemma – should I support the country of my birth or my new home country? Just like religion and language, I inherited my love for the Indian cricket team too.
Champions Trophy 2017 .IndianLink
I cried from the heartbreaks when they lost big matches, and ecstatically celebrated when they won. Australia was my second favourite team even as a child, and is now my chosen home where I hope to raise my child and make my mark. How do I resolve that dilemma?

Norman Tebbit, a conservative politician from the UK, once proposed a highly controversial assimilation test for immigrants – ‘Which cricket team do you cheer for?’ – using sports team loyalty as a test of national loyalty.

- Advertisement -

Ideological successors to Tebbit worldwide, endorse mutations of that idea and our very own ‘Australian Values Test’ being debated in our Parliament right now is a version of it. My feelings towards the tests are ambiguous. While Tebbit is an old world bigot, his test in isolation is a legitimate concern for countries welcoming new citizens.
Some immigrants swap their passports readily, but refuse to back their new ‘home teams’, even vociferously cheering against them. Those massive crowds in Indian blue jerseys must be disheartening to the English teams playing at home. Yet, I understand the first generation immigrant’s frustrations with economic and social mobility finding an outlet through spectator sports. Behaviour during a sports match can’t make you an ‘anti-national’.
Even though I decided to cheer for Australia during that match, my heart wasn’t into it. Secretly I wished for an Indian victory. This happened each time the two teams played each other. Months later, I hit upon a capitalist idea to resolve my Hamlet dilemma. I simply introduced economics to the equation. Each time they played India, I placed a $25 bet on Australia. Their loss was now literally my loss. The investment created an incentive for my intentions. If not the heart, the head was totally into wishing for an Australian victory. My Indian friends hated the idea, but it worked for me very well.
Tebbit would approve.
I placed another bet recently, on India beating Pakistan in the Champions Trophy 2017 Final. Waqar Younis once said that cricket between India and Pakistan is somewhere between sports and war. Extremists on both sides exploit escalated emotions during the matches to their political advantage. A steady rightward tilt in both countries meant that the Final was among the most hyped in recent memory. Inevitably, Kashmir got caught up in the middle and the Twitter spat on the topic reminded me of the Tebbit Test.
A Twitter comment tried to exploit the cricket match to make a political point about support to Pakistan. Gautam Gambhir, with his usual bluster, then pulled off the admirable feat of combining Twitter clichés with a Chinese reference. This spat didn’t make mainstream news only because Kashmiris celebrating Pakistan’s victory aren’t news anymore. Support to Pakistan has existed for nearly seventy years, even if the intensity ebbed and flowed. Yet, much of India remains blissfully unaware of the loyalties of the average Kashmiri.
In fact, I grew up seeing celebrations of Pakistan’s victories even in the sleepy south-central towns of Warangal and Nizamabad. There still are pockets in India where this happens. Every few years, a new generation of Indians discovers that phenomenon and assumes that their imperious outrage will somehow make people change sides. My own experiments with economic incentives made me wonder if enough was done to switch those loyalties. I just don’t know why it still happens.
The real question remains, who should the Kashmiris cheer for? Even after nearly seven decades, they aren’t convinced that they should cheer for India. No amount of economic incentive or political effort could convince them so far. Can you apply the Tebbit Test here and conclude that Kashmiris are ‘anti-national’? Probably not. This is, in fact, nothing like the Tebbit test because Kashmiris are not immigrants carrying over loyalties from a foreign land. Both their residence and loyalty have remained constant, while the border politics around them kept changing. Perhaps, in a highly complex situation like Kashmir, loyalty tests are futile. For the small pockets in the rest of the country, less so.
Imagine for a second that the final was between India and England, and India had won the contest. No doubt the massive Indian community in UK, most of them British citizens, would have celebrated boisterously. What would Norman Tebbit say?
No, scratch that. Tebbit doesn’t matter anymore.
What would Gautam Gambhir say?

- Advertisement -

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Ep8: Indian links in Indigenous Australian poet Ali Cobby Eckermann’s life

To celebrate NAIDOC week 2020 (between 8-15 November) I spoke to Yakunytjatjara poet Ali Cobby Eckermann about her time in India where she taught...

Ep 7: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

  The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Ep 6: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

  It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Latest News

AUSvIND: Battered India pull off greatest Test series win of all...

  Ten first-choice players unavailable or injured for at least part of the series, including the talismanic captain who happens to be the best player....
dhoni, rishabh pant, rohit sharma, tim paine, r ashwin, stump mic moments, ashwin sledging, sledging, funny moments, stump mic teasing

Candid convos caught by stump mics

  A lot of the time cheeky stump mics catch candid conversations on the pitch that become immortalised on Youtube. Here are some of those...
cheteshwar pujara

WATCH: Pujara puts his body on the line at the Gabba

  A battered and bruised Indian cricket team is soldiering on as the final day of the 4th cricket test match goes to a thrilling...

Biryani Bonanza: 3 delicious recipes to try this Republic Day

  Talk about biryanis, and you’ll encounter way too many FAQs. Do you cook the rice and meat separately, or together? Do you use the...
curry and rice

“Stop cooking curry”: when neighbours complain about ‘smelly’ Indian food

  When 29-year-old Vaibhav Pokhriyal moved into his new apartment in Dee Why, he never would’ve guessed what a stir (no pun intended) his cooking...