Two men, one mission

Gandhi and Tagore's intriguing relationship unravelled in letters

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Gandhi and Tagore.
We’ve uttered these two names together so many times in the same breath, you’d think they were cut from the same cloth.

And so it came as a bit of a surprise to learn that they rarely agreed on anything. Other than, of course, that they wanted India to be rid of the British.

A recent theatre production brought to life the strange relationship between the two men, fraught with disagreements but nurtured with much mutual respect.

The Bangalore Little Theatre (BLT) was in Sydney last week to stage a play called The Prophet and the Poet at the Parramatta South campus of Western Sydney University. The play, or more precisely docu-theatre, was based on the conversations shared between Mahatma Gandhi and Rabindranath Tagore in their private letters during the freedom struggle. The two leaders had frank discussions on many issues in their letters exchanged over 25 years.

A scene from The Prophet and the Poet

In the 90-minute staging, it is the conversations between the two men that takes centre stage, rather than portrayals of the protagonists themselves. Even the sets were minimal, emphasising only on the intriguing exchanges that took place between 1915 and 1941.

The two men, both fascinating personalities, disagreed on everything that they discussed, but had genuine love and respect for each other despite their differences. This delicate balance was beautifully showcased throughout this dialogue-heavy play, based on archival research by Prof. Sabyasachi Bhattacharya, former Vice-Chancellor of Visva Bharati University, West Bengal.

The play got off the mark with slideshows of original letters written by the two men. In these long-winded notes, they debated various political issues on which they professed differing standpoints: on Hindi as national language (a debate that continues nearly a century later!); Tagore’s criticism about Gandhi’s non-cooperation movement, Swaraj and Gandhi’s absence at the Round Table Conference; Gandhi’s visit to Shantiniketan; Tagore’s concern on Gandhi’s frequent fasting.

Their last letters in 1940 were particularly interesting.

While actor Minti Jain narrated the play, actors Naveen Tater and Karan Singh discussed the letters of Gandhi and Tagore. These three actors of Bangalore Little Theatre could win any international memory competition – effortlessly delivering innumerable pages of intricate dialogue, stunning with their extraordinary memory power. They later admitted to hours of rigorous practice!

Actors Naveen, Karan and Minti with their stage manager Murtuza Khetty

Bangalore Little Theatre is one of India’s oldest theatre groups, which has produced over 200 plays in 50 years. It is known for its creative and quality productions, training workshops and outreach programs.

About The Prophet and the Poet, actor Naveen Tater told Indian Link, “This play has been performed 106 times.”

He revealed that having worked in this thought-provoking play has been a great learning experience for him personally.

“The actual correspondence in the letters is interspersed with imaginary dialogues but based on historic details,” he described. “These are not full letters. These are just excerpts of the actual letters. Actually they wrote long letters to each other, both being voracious writers. Their language was such that we had to relearn a lot of English! There were so many words we don’t use today, so much of grammar we don’t utilise. It is a grammar that’s forgotten. We had to learn enunciations for this play. A lot of our own language went through development when we rehearsed for this.”

The learning had not been restricted to language alone, Naveen offered. “You know, every staging of this play is different – we end up discovering something new! Perhaps this is what they intended. After every performance, we learn new things and we keep revising the content.”

Though the play is set in the pre-independence era, the messages that the leaders conveyed via their letters are relevant even now. 

“They would probably be relevant 500 years from now,” Naveen laughed. “The crux of the whole thing that these two contemporary leaders shared, would be the same. That is their greatness. They were not born great, as they had their own share of struggles. What is interesting is that they do not agree with each other on almost anything except for the fact that India needs independence. Despite the dissent, they have love and respect for each other and that’s a very delicate balance which today the world has lost. That is the message that this play brings. Dissent can sometimes be an engine for growth. You can only thrive with dissent. If you suppress dissent, then there is no thriving.”

A great message for today’s highly polarised world.

For me personally, the play was revealing in many ways. So far, I’ve known Gandhi through his books. But here in this play, I was seeing another Gandhi: a Gandhi through the eyes of a peer, an opponent, a true friend – Tagore.

It was Tagore, laying bare before us, a Gandhi we could never have known.

- Advertisement -

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -


Let’s Talk Boosters: Indian Link podcast

  In LET'S TALK BOOSTERS, a new podcast series by Indian Link, host Ekta Sharma quizzes Dr Kritman Dhamoon of Blacktown Hospital Sydney about booster...
Frontline worker Parita Patel (inset). Image supplied

‘Serving the community’: COVID testing in remote NSW

  The past two years have been a rollercoaster of COVID-19 related turmoil; from isolating lockdowns, closed borders, to trying to help Indians in the...

Ep 9: What do young Indians want from love?

  Growing up in Indian culture, most of us know that love has never been as popular as marriage. Even in the movies, the main...
- Advertisement -

Latest News

gurpreet singh

#MyWork: Prison officer Gurpreet Singh

  Sydney’s GURPREET SINGH tells RAJNI ANAND LUTHRA about his work with Corrective Services NSW. My job title Deputy Superintendent Classifications and Placement, at the Silverwater Correctional...
Bhaukaal 2

Review: Bhaukaal season 2 (MX Player)

  There is no pre-defined meaning to the title, 'Bhaukaal', but colloquially in the local North Indian lingo, it egoistically means "in one's own style,...

Auntyji on the ethics of cross-racial surrogacy

  Dear Auntyji I don’t know if you have watched a Hindi film on surrogacy on Netflix called Mimi, but I have a question for you...
book review rashida tayabali

BOOK REVIEW: Life after Ali by Rashida Tayabali

  The story begins with Tasneem, a mother of two adolescent children, attending her husband Ali’s funeral at a mosque in Sydney. Ali’s sudden and untimely...

 REVIEW: Mission Frontline season 2 (Discovery+)

  The series is like a documentary. It introduces the audience to the armed forces, close and upfront, with the help of celebrities. AT A GLANCE ...