Monday, January 25, 2021

Blues, spiced with Hindustani

Reading Time: 3 minutes

Canadian musician Harry Manx brought his particular brand of fusion and his mohan veena to the MEMO Music Hall in St Kilda

Award-winning Canadian musician Harry Manx looks at first like your typical Blues/Americana/Folk musician, with his grizzled white beard, black wool hat and blue jeans. But look closer, because the slide guitar he holds is in fact not a guitar at all, but a mohan veena, given to him by Vishwa Mohan Bhatt – its Grammy Award-winning inventor. The instrument has an extra layer of sympathetic strings, making it a hybrid of western and eastern sound.
As Manx, who started out in Blues as a “roadie” at the age of fifteen, and started his recording career at the age of 46, plays some opening chords, I almost think I’m imagining the silken sound of a raag. But through the song I hear Indian classical meends, or slides, mixed with blues, and the finishing chords are distinctly Hindustani.
Harry Manx.Indian Link
Manx laughs as he tells me that his music is sometimes described as “Indo-Blues”. This, he says frankly, is mostly so he can be placed in a category, making it easier for his audience to find his music in a store. In reality, he switches deftly between styles just as he switches between mohan veena, slide guitar, and banjo on stage. He is in fact more about adding the flavour of India rather than a conscious and consistent mixing of Indian classical with western music.
“My time spent in India gave my music a little spice…I can’t seem to play any other way now,” he says.
Manx originally travelled to India in 1986 in pursuit of meditation, not music. The links between music and spirituality eventually led to him to Jaipur and Vishwa Mohan Bhatt, from whom he learned the mohan veena for five years, practicing five hours a day. The greatest difficulty with learning Hindustani classical, he says, was connecting with the sound as a westerner.
“You don’t grow up with that sound… it sounds very foreign at first,” Manx says.
Harry Manx.Indian Link
He never had any intention of mixing the two styles, but ultimately he noticed commonalities between some Blues scales and Indian ragas, particularly in night ragas with their “heavy” feel.
Listening to some of his songs that have been given this treatment, I can see what he means, especially as the improvisations of renowned organist and keyboard player Clayton Doley meld, rather than jar against it. On the other hand, I find some songs that have been given the “eastern spice” too eclectic, almost psychedelic. The sound of these pieces, to my Indian ears, is more reminiscent of hippies and hashish than classical Hindustani music.
However, I respect the fact Manx is open about the difficulties of presenting true Indian classical to his almost exclusively western audience.
“First of all, I’m not that qualified to do it, but second of all, I can’t hold their interest for long enough.” By framing and ‘referencing’ Indian classical in a Blues context, he believes it becomes more accessible to western listeners. He wants the music to connect with them in the same way he connected with classical music in India.
Harry Manx.Indian Link
Looking around curiously at the audience as he performs, I’m not sure how successful he’s been. There seems to be a kind of frozen, polite quality to the way they listen to his Indianised Blues pieces, compared to the palpable enthusiasm he receives while playing classic Blues and Americana songs. And despite his frequent invitation for questions, nobody asks anything about Indian music.
But then again, as someone who lets his music ‘unfold’ with no fixed approach, Manx is hardly on a mission. In an era where fusion for fusion’s sake is ‘in vogue’, this is refreshing in itself.

- Advertisement -
Aparna Ananthuni
Aparna is an aspiring writer of historical fiction and fantasy for young adults and children. She also loves reading, drawing and Indian classical music, and often develops strange obsessions like typewriter-collecting.

Related Articles



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


Ep8: Indian links in Indigenous Australian poet Ali Cobby Eckermann’s life

To celebrate NAIDOC week 2020 (between 8-15 November) I spoke to Yakunytjatjara poet Ali Cobby Eckermann about her time in India where she taught...

Ep 7: In the case of Sushant Singh Rajput

  The torrid and high-octane Sushant Singh Rajput case has been fodder for Indian people and press for the last few months. The actor’s tragic...

Ep 6: The Indian LGBTQ+ community in 2020

  It’s been two years since the world’s largest democracy repealed the draconian Section 377 which used to allow discrimination against homosexual people. Only this...

Latest News

aboriginal flag

Indigenous Australians, living without conciliation

  I am a citizen of Australia and yet I am not a citizen of the nation I reside in within Australia. This anomaly affects...

The night we fled our home in Kashmir

  “26 January is coming up, memsaab,” the milkman I had known for years said to me. “Maybe you should put up a black flag...
the white tiger netflix

Review: The White Tiger (Netflix)

  "Don't believe for a second there's a million-rupee game show you can win to get out of it". That's Balram Halwai in The White...
lilly singh

WATCH: Lilly Singh as Sima Taparia in “Indian Matchbreaking”

  Whether we liked it or not, most of us gave into the Sima Taparia craze during lockdown. Within days, we'd all binged on Netflix's...
karl rock

From New Zealand to New Delhi: Meet YouTube’s Karl Rock

  When Karl Rock picks up the phone (with a cheerful ‘Namaste!’ no less), his New Zealand accent is apparent. That is, until he bursts...